When a will is opened and heirs find it differs from what they expected, the first question is: can anything be done? Sometimes it can, but only under certain conditions and within a structured legal process. "I don't like it" or "it isn't fair" does not in itself constitute a ground. A will expresses the wishes of the deceased, and the court tends to respect them unless a real defect is proven.
The information is general only, and does not replace a review of your own case.
What is an objection to a will
For a will to be binding, an application is made to the Registrar of Inheritance for a probate order. The application is published, and anyone with an interest in the estate, such as an heir by law or a beneficiary under an earlier will, may file an objection within a time frame that follows the filing of the application for a probate order. An objection asks that the will not be given effect, in whole or in part. For the ordinary process, where there is no objection, see Probate Order: Stages and Timing.
Who can object
Anyone whose rights are affected by the will, for example:
- An heir by law who was left out or received less than the statute would give (see Inheritance Order).
- A beneficiary under an earlier will whose share the new will changed.
- A creditor of the estate or another party with a direct legal interest.
Someone who is not a relative and has no interest in the estate generally cannot object.
Recognized grounds
The law sets out several reasons for which a will may be invalidated or limited. The main ones:
- Formal defect: the will was not made as required, for example witnesses were missing or it was not signed properly. The valid ways of making a will are described in How to Make a Will in Israel.
- Lack of capacity: a claim that when the will was made the testator did not understand the meaning of the act, for example because of a cognitive illness. Such a claim usually rests on medical records and witness evidence.
- Undue influence: a claim that someone exploited the testator's dependence on them and impaired their free choice.
- Coercion, duress or fraud: a claim that the testator was forced to sign, or was misled about the content or circumstances of the document.
- Mistake: a claim that a provision was made on the basis of a material mistake.
- A later will or a revoked will: a claim that a newer will exists, or that the submitted will was revoked.
Each claim must be proven, and the burden usually falls on the objector. Undue influence and lack of capacity are particularly hard to prove, so all the evidence supporting the objector's claims should be gathered early.
What is not a ground
- A will that seems "unfair" or unequal between children, when it was made properly by a competent person.
- Disagreements over the sentimental value of an asset.
- The fact that the deceased changed their mind and wrote a new will.
How the process runs
- Publication of the application for a probate order. The notice states a deadline for objections. The deadline is short, so do not wait or delay.
- Filing the objection with the Registrar of Inheritance, setting out the grounds and supporting documents. If the deadline passes, an extension may be requested, but there is no certainty that the request will be granted.
- Transfer to court. Where there is a factual dispute, the Registrar transfers the file to the Family Court.
- Court proceedings: pleadings, disclosure of documents, witness examination and sometimes a medical expert opinion.
- Judgment or settlement. Many cases end by agreement or mediation, so it is worth considering that option along the way.
Such proceedings can take time, so assess in advance what you want to achieve and weigh the risk against the benefit.
A word on mediation and agreements
Not every dispute needs to end in a judgment. In many families the parties reach an agreement that divides the estate differently from the will, and the court approves it. The advantages of agreement are preserving family relationships, saving time and avoiding the exposure of personal details in public proceedings. Even if a legal proceeding is eventually chosen, it is always worth leaving the door open to dialogue.
What to prepare before approaching a lawyer
- A copy of the will and any earlier will, if known.
- Medical records of the deceased from the time the will was made, where accessible.
- Details of the witnesses and of whoever prepared the will (a lawyer or notary).
- A chronology of events: who was in contact with the deceased, who cared for them, when the will was signed.
- A list of the known assets of the estate.
Common mistakes
- Missing the deadline to file an objection.
- Relying on feelings and emotions rather than legal evidence.
- Acting without a lawyer early on, and signing documents that bear on your rights.
- Taking action against siblings and close family members without first exploring dialogue, which sometimes saves time and money.
Frequently asked questions
Can a will be challenged after a probate order has been issued? There is a route for cancelling a probate order in certain circumstances, but it is a separate and harder proceeding. Check it with a lawyer.
Can an oral will be challenged? Yes. An oral will is subject to special conditions and limits, and the claim will usually focus on whether those conditions were met.
Does an objection delay distribution of the estate? Usually yes, until the dispute is decided.
In summary
An objection to a will is a legitimate tool where there is a basis for objecting, but it is limited to defined grounds and requires evidence and timely action. If you are considering objecting, or an objection was filed against a will in which you are a beneficiary, you are welcome to contact us for an initial review. On the field generally see Wills & Inheritance, and on advance planning that reduces disputes see also Mutual Will Between Spouses.
The information in this article is general, is not legal advice, and does not replace a review of the specific case.
The information on this site is general and is not legal advice. Attorney advertising.
Related articles
- Probate Order for a Will
Probate order in Israel: who files an application for a probate order, which documents are needed, the stages before the Registrar of Inheritance, what happens when an objection is filed and what affects timing.
- Writing a Will in Israel
A guide to writing a will in Israel: the types of wills, what makes a will valid, what happens without one, and the mistakes worth avoiding.
- Mutual Will Between Spouses
A mutual will between spouses in Israel: what it is, how it differs from two separate wills, what to ask before signing and when it can be changed.

