Skip to main content

Real Estate

Tenant Rights in Urban Renewal

Urban renewal and demolish-and-rebuild projects in Israel: what residents are entitled to, which clauses to check in the developer agreement and how it is advisable to prepare before signing.

Adv. David Vakrat5 min read

A model of a low old plaster building beside a taller new travertine building, with a small brass key between them on a light oak table.

A notice of a demolish-and-rebuild project (pinui binui) or urban renewal in your building raises questions and concerns. What do you get in return? How long will it take? And what happens if the developer runs into trouble midway? In such a project the residents are asked to sign a complex, long-term agreement, so it is worth understanding in advance what to check.

The information is general only, and does not replace a review of your own case.

What is urban renewal

Urban renewal is a process in which the residents are evacuated, the old building they lived in is demolished and a new one built in its place (pinui binui), or the building is strengthened and extended (additions and renovations under a suitable plan). The developer finances the work and receives additional building rights that let it sell new apartments. The residents receive a new apartment, usually larger and improved, without paying its full value.

What residents usually receive

The terms are set in negotiation and in the agreement. These are common items, with no guarantee that they will be obtained in every project:

  • A replacement apartment of the same size or larger than the existing one.
  • Parking, storage and a safe room, as agreed.
  • An elevator and improvement of the building's infrastructure and facade.
  • Rent or compensation for the period between evacuation and occupancy.
  • Delivery by a defined date, with compensation for delay.

The project stages in brief

  1. An initial approach by a developer and the setting up of a committee or representatives for the residents.
  2. Choosing the developer and a lawyer for the residents, and sometimes also a supervisor or appraiser.
  3. Negotiation of the terms of the deal and the wording of the agreement.
  4. Signing by the residents, usually before a notary or a lawyer.
  5. Approval of the plan and a building permit from the authorities, a stage that can take a long time.
  6. Evacuation, demolition and construction. During this period the residents live in rented housing, usually at the developer's expense.
  7. Delivery of the new apartments and their registration in the land registry in the residents' names.

Remember that any stage may be delayed, so the agreement should reflect this, particularly regarding rent and delivery dates. Ask who is responsible for delays outside your control, and what happens if they last for years.

What residents should check in the agreement

  • Dates: when the evacuation is, when delivery is, and what happens in case of delay. For rights in case of late delivery see Late Apartment Delivery.
  • Description of the new apartment: area, floor, orientation, specification, parking and storage, and the measurement method.
  • Security for residents: a guarantee or other security for the developer's obligations, particularly if it does not complete the project.
  • The developer's standing: experience, previous projects and financial capacity. Check them carefully.
  • Rent payments: the amount, when paid, and whether it is tied to the actual construction period.
  • Land registry: how the rights in the new apartment will be registered, and whether there are cautionary notes during the interim period. See Caveat in the Land Registry.
  • Taxation: the consequences of the transaction for residents. Consult an accountant or tax adviser before signing.
  • Exit clauses: what happens if the project stops, and whether residents can return to their apartment.

A representative and a lawyer for the residents

In many projects the residents appoint a committee or representatives to manage the negotiation, and a lawyer who represents the residents and not the developer. Make sure that:

  • The lawyer represents the interests of the residents only.
  • It is clear who pays the lawyer, and that there is no conflict of interest with the developer.
  • Each resident receives an explanation of the agreement before signing, and has the right to ask questions and get answers.

The required majority and residents who refuse

For a project to advance, a defined majority of apartment owners is usually required, under the statute and the plan. Where a minority refuses, legal proceedings may follow in which the court examines whether the offer is reasonable and fair. A resident who refuses to sign has certain routes open, but must weigh each decision carefully. Check the matter with a lawyer before responding.

Common mistakes

  • Signing quickly, under pressure from neighbors or the developer.
  • Relying on oral promises that were not included in the agreement.
  • Not checking the developer and the projects it has carried out to date.
  • Ignoring security and the question of what happens if the project is not completed.
  • Not clarifying the tax consequences before signing.

Frequently asked questions

Can changes be requested to the proposed agreement? Yes, and it is advisable. An initial draft is usually an opening point, and there is room to negotiate, especially when the residents are organized and act together.

Do older residents or residents with disabilities receive special treatment? Some projects agree special arrangements, such as phased evacuation. It is worth requesting this in advance.

What happens if I want to sell in the middle of the process? The answer depends on the agreement and the stage of the project, and should be checked case by case. Check whether the agreement restricts transfer of rights.

In summary

Urban renewal can be an opportunity, but it is also a long-term commitment. It is worth understanding what you receive, what is secured and what happens when something goes wrong. If you were offered such an agreement, you are welcome to contact us to review it before signing. On the field generally see Real Estate, and on checks in property transactions see also Checks Before Buying an Apartment.

The information in this article is general, is not legal advice, and does not replace a review of the specific case.

Related practice areaReal EstatePurchase, sale, leasing, projects and urban renewal

The information on this site is general and is not legal advice. Attorney advertising.

  • Late Apartment Delivery

    Late delivery of an apartment from a developer in Israel: the Sale (Apartments) Law, compensation, what to document and steps to take before court.

  • Caveat in the Land Registry

    A caveat (warning note) in the Israeli land registry: what it is, which rights it protects, how it is registered and what it means when one appears on a property you want to buy.

  • Checks Before Buying an Apartment

    What a lawyer checks before you buy a resale apartment in Israel: land registry extract, liens and notes, building permits, debts and taxes, payments and the contract.

Back to all articles

One conversation,and you’ll know exactly where you stand.